America's North Shore Journal » Tsunami relief
Comparison of Haiti donations to Katrina and the tsunami
Comparisons between the American fund raising results for Haitian earthquake relief and the efforts after Hurricane Katrina and the Southeast Asian tsunami are inevitable. Private giving by Americans, individuals, foundations and corporations has always been generous. Our economy is significantly weaker than it was in 2004-2005 and that may be the biggest factor affecting giving to date. Some of the historical numbers include money raised by churches. Those collections have happened but have not been reported publicly as far as can be determined for the Haiti relief effort. Here are the current results as recorded on this site. The column titles are links to the articles on that topic. HAITI QUAKE HURRICANE KATRINA INDONESIAN TSUNAMI Date: Jan 12, 2010 Aug 29, 2005 Dec 26, 2004 Plus 6 days $156,044,390 Plus 7 days $207,882,580 Plus 11 days $632,783,990 $401,784,551 Plus 13 days $306,797,596 $456,916,726 This table will be updated as the … Read entire article »
Filed under: Americans, Analysis, Charity, Disasters, Original writing, Reporting, Stingy List
Indonesia Opens Tsunami Museum
Indonesia has opened a $5.6 million museum to commemorate the 230,000 people who died in the 2004 Asian tsunami. The four-level building in hardest-hit Aceh province exhibits photographs of victims, stories of survivors and an electronic simulation of the massive undersea earthquake that triggered the 30-foot-high waves. It also describes the tremendous outpouring of support from governments, companies and individuals in the aftermath of the Dec. 26, 2004 disaster, which caused death and destruction in a dozen nations. More than $13 billion was pledged to house and feed survivors and to rebuild devastated coasts. Fox News … Read entire article »
Filed under: Charity, Disasters, Stingy List, Tsunami relief
Tsunami Relief Redirect
Thanks to Glenn Reynolds for the link. It’s obsolete, so go here: LINK That’s the entire category. … Read entire article »
Filed under: Stingy List
Tsunami and Sharia
Sunday Times: Tsunami survivors given the lash Disaster donations help Islamic vigilante force impose punishments on women As the man who managed the Stingy List, I can say without fear that this story is tripe, balderdash, hooey. Readers of this blog have known for years that sharia is a growing menace in Indonesia. The formerly august Sunday Times of London conflates the growth of sharia with the donations for tsunami relief without producing one iota of evidence. Indeed, buried in the story is the good news. The peace between the rebels and the national government is holding. The first free election in Aceh history was just held successfully. And… a former rebel has been elected Governor. It doesn’t get much better than this. There is no evidence that any donations have been diverted to the … Read entire article »
Filed under: Charity, Commentary, Disasters, Original writing, Tsunami relief
Aceh – Women and the Tsunami
Please note that all the stories here are about women in Aceh. The final exerpt is very important because it is from a study done very recently on life for the women of Aceh. Note that violence against women is not pervasive nor is it related to tsunami aid in any way. Oxfam: Mahmulia’s navy blue t-shirt is flecked with yellow and her hair is speckled with brown paint. “This is my second day of painting,†she giggles. Oxfam is training Mahmulia and 36 other women to paint the new homes being built in their village, Beuring In, which was destroyed by the tsunami. Before the tsunami, house painting was a male-dominated occupation. Women’s activities tended to center on working in the rice fields or running a street stall. The unprecedented scale of construction … Read entire article »
Filed under: Charity, Disasters, Tsunami relief
That Wacky Sunday Times of London
Sunday Times: Tsunami survivors given the lash Disaster donations help Islamic vigilante force impose punishments on women Now, that’s alarming. But here are the paragraphs that support this assertion. blank space intentional Here’s what the story really says: International aid workers and Indonesian women’s organisations are now expressing dismay that the flow of foreign cash for reconstruction has allowed the government to spend scarce money on a new bureaucracy and religious police to enforce puritan laws, such as the compulsory wearing of headscarves. Some say there are more “sharia police†than regular police on the local government payroll and that many of them are aggressive young men. The irony is that sharia was first introduced into Aceh as part of a package of measures that ultimately succeeded in making peace in the long-running guerrilla war between … Read entire article »
Filed under: Charity, Commentary, Disasters, Original writing, Tsunami relief
Culture of Giving
BBC Philanthropy is so well established it has spawned its own academic discipline. New York University has a department of philanthropy. There is also the Chronicle of Philanthropy. I have even attended a philanthropy workshop in the bowels of Congress, where rich Americans learned how to give their money away and how to make sure it was spent on the right causes. Whether it is the quest for a legacy, the desire to change the world, the determination not to spoil one’s children or simply the tax code, Americans – wealthy and not so wealthy – are giving their dollars away by the lorry load. And the rest of the world has a long way to catch up. The author takes a shot at the United States government by suggesting that private Americans gave more … Read entire article »
Filed under: Charity, Commentary, Original writing, Stingy List, Tsunami relief
Pork Busted
Think Progress e-mails me with a fine example of pork. The junior Senator from Mississippi seems to have inserted into an aid package a provision that would advance Northrop Grumman up to a half billion dollars towards future contract payments by the government, as an assist in recovering from hurricane damages. They’re insured and are “discussing” the matter with their insurance company. This is just an interest free loan by the taxpayers. For the non-accountants, the revenue number may be impressive but it does not reflect cash flow. It includes accounts receivable and possibly amortizations of cash received in prior periods but recognized in the current period. Their 4.6% profit in 2005 is modest, to say the least, and again does not reflect cash in hand but just the net of … Read entire article »
Filed under: Blogging, Commentary, Disasters, Gulf Reconstruction, Original writing, Pork Busters, Tsunami relief

Tsunami Aid Not Given, Not Used
December 20th, 2006 | Comments Off
My compilation of private American aid for tsunami relief, the Stingy List, went over a billion dollars. I was less than enthusiastic about the pledges of various governments, and it would seem, for good reason. BBC Newsnight Renewed civil war in the north of Sri Lanka has hampered the rebuilding effort there but it is does not explain the performance of governments in meeting their pledges. According to the UN DAD database Spain promised $60m and delivered less than $1m. France pledged $79m and came up with just over $1m. When we contacted them they said “all the figures are confirmed, therefore you can be sure they are accurate”. The Chinese promised even more – $301m – and delivered – just $1m. In the Maldives, Kuwait allocated just under $10m but they have yet to … Read entire article »
Filed under: Charity, Commentary, Disasters, Original writing, Tsunami relief